Mr. Saxobeat (Radio Edit)
Alexandra Stan

Created by: Melanie420
Submitted: about 2 years ago
Ranked: almost 2 years ago
Source: Saxobeats
Tags:
Eurodance, pop, english, Jindax, Moca Loca, Melanie420, Im Poppy, Lisa, Mochathemapper, crewmate, Jesusquaver
BPM: 127
Length: 3:11
Passes/Fails: 451 / 952

[7K] 23.22 - Jindax' 7k saxy thinking emoji

Pending
Suggestion
Reazy Fwoof
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/320731933069934592/1066758859655483562/image.png

Past this, make a long not anchor to represent your guitar and shift the stream around it, it'd make a lot more sense than how it currently is. Or just remove the long notes all together as they just currently are not implemented well into the stream both representation and how they play.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

mostly ignored this one but tried to make the lns more playable

Pending
Issue
Reazy Fwoof
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

I agree with Subtlr, the minijacks on this transition need to be shifted they don't represent the melody well since there isn't any kind of repeated sound there.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

ok then

Pending
Issue
Reazy Fwoof
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

104226|7 Remove this double
104462|6 Make this and 104934|1 double for the vocal


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

sure

Pending
Issue
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

Why is this a 6 note chord the sound is literally not that loud


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

it's funny :D

Pending
Suggestion
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

jin you might be tone deaf why you put this note on column one when it's higher pitched lol, same goes for 141076|1.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

ok

Pending
Issue
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

This sound should not be a grace note lol


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

ok

Pending
Suggestion
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

what the hell? Please download YaLTeR's Misc plugin and find any other weird anchors that aren't supposed to be anywhere because this is kind of weird to play.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

it's literally on purpose man

Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

denyiend

Pending
Suggestion
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

Why was this sound omitted? Sounds like a very clear sound to chart and since you charted the sound at 25801 as graces I don't see any reason why you would not chart this sound at 40919 aswell, seems very odd imo


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

ok

Pending
Suggestion
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

The chorus has some weird patterning choices making for some uncomfortable trills that happen on one side of the hand and just makes it not fun to play, some examples are 34659|2,34777|1,34895|2,35013|3,35131|2,35249|3,35249|1, 31706|5,31824|4,31824|7,31942|5,32060|6,32060|4,32179|7, 35486|6,35604|7,35604|5,35722|4,35840|5,35840|6,35958|7, and much more others.


Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

Overall I think you need to revise some of the pattern choices here and think about how the player feels while playing this map because right now there are just many hand imbalances and uncomfortable patterning (like 53556|5,53556|7,53675|6,53793|5,53793|7 just being a random one handed X pattern) and playtest it more thoroughly, even if you have to do it downrated. For the other choruses I'm too lazy to point out all of them so you can find them yourself :D

Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

bro nah i won't be making a whole revision of the map i'm just gonna spot the obvious mistakes

Pending
Issue
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

Missing note? There's a kick sound here and you seem to chart it beforehand on 25919|4 so I don't see any reason to omit this.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

ok

Pending
Suggestion
Subtlr
Ranking Supervisor
almost 2 years ago

Using graces like these in contrast to the whole map is much harder and makes an unnecessary 1/4th jack for any notes after it like these 25919|2,25919|4 which just feels out of place comparing to the chorus and other parts of the map. The grace density is not supported by the sound it tries to represent because the sound is not as loud and apparent as other sounds you've charted as chords, rather than making the chords dense make the total chord count of this grace lower to like 4 or 5, currently people with 6KRO keyboards have a hard time hitting these notes for something not so apparent.


Jindax
User
almost 2 years ago

skill issue