The Holy Grail
Blind Guardian

Back To Mapset Page
Created by: Storn
Submitted: over 4 years ago
Ranked: almost 4 years ago
Source: Beyond the Red Mirror
Tags:
The Disturbance of the Here and Now (Reprise), Symphonic, Power, Metal, Hansi Kürsch
BPM: 167
Length: 5:57
Passes/Fails: 243 / 566

[4K] 23.16 - Magna Eterna

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Try to not omit these sounds, add a note here, 352852, 354289 and 355727

Denied
Suggestion
Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Add one note here, 347643|3 and 347822|2, strong drum

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Strong drums again, add one note on every sound like this

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

thats not a transition

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can follow the same example has i pointed before on https://quavergame.com/mapset/map/25609/mods#mod_1702, same pitch, same guitar.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Here we got a snap transition, for make it more clear, you can add one note for emphasize the cymbal and make that transition more noticeable


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

not a fan of notes just cus its a transition

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Why is this different to 274888?


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

snare vs no snare

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Denied
Suggestion
Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Since you followed drums like this on 259798 and 260158, you can add one note here


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

theres already notes there for the durms

Denied
Suggestion
Ignored
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Why are these LNs, revert to normal notes?


Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Sorry, ignore this.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can add one note here, 255667 and 255846 for follow the consistency of similar patterns


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

consistency in not having notes here.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

theres no note here to add.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

This part feels like it needs to be connected with more normal notes, because yea, you are following the drums like 231325|4,231415|2,231505|4, but the problem is that in patterns like 231775 the pattern changed without reason. This makes the pattern a little uncomfortable on gameplay because you are totally focused on the solo. Consider add the missing notes, not necessarily adding two notes per drums, just one on the missing parts.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i'm not entirely sure what you're talking about but i assume you mean the missing cymbals in this section. i've gone and added them back in.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Swap this for emphasize the first column only for drums, also for this, you have to move 231236|1 to the second column for evade the jack


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

No, thats not my style.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Because of cymbal, you can add a note on the first column and move 230427|1 to the fourth column

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

This pattern has the same sound as 206804, erase this notes


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

the sounds are different. there is a snare on those notes, the jumps are justified.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Overuse of the second column, swap them

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Don't lose the focus, you are missing triples here, add one note here as you did on similar points before

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

i can hear the cymbal and the drum here, add one note


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i think thats just bleed from the last cymbal. I double checked with a live video and while its probably different, there was also not a cymbal on that note.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

The notes are justified, but i am concerned about notes like: 167822|2,168002|1, 168541|4,168721|3, etc. because you can do this patterns like jacks for justify the guitar at his max point, i did a suggerence here if you want to follow it and for make it more attractive at gameplay.

https://i.imgur.com/ttW04eh.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/ODPy4CX.jpg

at this way, you are following the pitch of the guitar, emphasizing the strongest parts of the sound.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i've changed up the section a bit. i'm keeping the section like it is, but rearranging the notes a bit.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

I can't anything that can justify that triple, d e l e t


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

from what i hear there is a faint cymbal in the background, so thats probably what it was for

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Start of a pattern and with cymbal, you can add one more note.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Cymbal and drum (?), you can add one or two notes here, at 144110 and 146984


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

this is a calmer section of the song and the cymbals aren't very crashy. adding notes in for them kind of muddies up the section.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Same as https://quavergame.com/mapset/map/25609/mods#mod_1689, apply to 136385 and 136745

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Since you followed the drums at 127224, continue adding notes as drums here and 130637


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

there's already notes there for the drums. we dont need more.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

if you followed https://quavergame.com/mapset/map/25609/mods#mod_1685, you can move the first note at the fourth column, move the second note to the first column and add a note at 103870, at this way you are emphasizing the gallop feeling and at the same time you are varying the pattern, making the trill mirrored.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

what?

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

the drum here is stronger than 103331 and maybe equally to 103152, you can add a note at the third column

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can swap this notes, it actually feels like you are reusing the columns too much


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

its called a trill. its supposed to use the same column.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

I forgot to mention that you can add at this kind of introductions one more note, since the cymbal is there flying and calling for help, 52134 here too and 55008


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i'm leaving some of these out. if i add a note for every cymbal the map will get lost in density. the ones i've left out aren't really crashes, and blend in with the rest of the cymbals that aren't being mapped.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Add a note as a cymbal

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Keep the consistency as 48721, the pattern feels like is cutting the music with the lack of density

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Since you added notes as a stream on 48721, add the same amount of notes at the blue lines, ending the pattern at 52044

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Add a note, strong pitch and you are not breaking the pattern adding it, just emphasizing it


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

there is already a note there.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

For make more variety and follow the pitch, add a note following the cymbal of the background, on 47643 too

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can swap these notes for follow the consistency and the pitch of the guitar


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i understand the issue here, but i've moved other notes around to fix it.

Denied
Suggestion
Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can add a note at the first column for follow the drum, move 40727|1 to the fourth column and move 40816|4 to the first column, at this way you are not breaking the pattern

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can add a note at the third column, move 39110|3 to second, move 39200|2 to first column and move 39289|1 to the third column


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

i could, but there is absolutely no reason you to.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Same as https://quavergame.com/mapset/map/25609/mods#mod_1662, but more necessary due to the lack of order here


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

????

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

ok i get the intention, but, as a suggerence too, you can add a note at this kind of points


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

there is already a not there and i dont see a reason to add more.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Did you forgot a note? because you are following the drums at the start of the pattern


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

no, there is definitely a note there.

Accepted
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Sound here, you can add one on second column and move 23481|2 to third column.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Since you added doubles at 22673, for emphasize the sound a little, you can convert 19798 at doubles and 22673 as triples.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

please read the map comments, this was already brought up there.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Strong noice and new transition, you can add one note here for emphasize the sound, like 18541, 18900, 19439, 20876, 21415, 21775 and 22313 (Click on "Tools/Go to object" and copypaste the numbers for go to the exact point)


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

theres already notes there??

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You actually added notes there, without any context, delete them or…:
------- you can add notes in all the white lines, since the drum is stronger there (like 11894 and 12254 for example) omiting this 14050 kind of transition of course, your choice at this point.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

thats exactly why those notes are there??

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

You can add there too, its the end of the introduction, let's end it with grace


Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Drum, cymbal, pitch, you can add one more note on that points.


Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

On this sections, you can add 1 note for emphasize the drum


Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

This sounds are stronger than the drums of before, you can add notes on these parts for emphasize them.


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

That is why they are jumps. they dont need more emphasis. i could in fact make them hands, but i think that would be less consistent with the chart as a whole and i'd rather just keep them as jumps

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

Since you are following the drums on 1116, add a note here and on 2553 for follow the consistency of the pattern


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

thats not how the structure works, and would make the chart more inconsistent. the sounds there do not deserve to be jumps and thus are not.

Denied
Suggestion
Skalim
User
almost 4 years ago

This should be more dense, Drum, synth and cymbal, and also the sound is generally strong than the rest of the sound


Storn
Creator
almost 4 years ago

The jump is already enough for this sound. having a hand would be overkill and doesn't work will the current layering scheme of the chart.